API (Allied Precision Industries) BDT250 (250W) vs K&H Pet Products Super Ice Eliminator 9001 (80W)

API (Allied Precision Industries) BDT250 (250W)

K&H Pet Products Super Ice Eliminator 9001 (80W)
The short answer
K&H Pet Products Super Ice Eliminator 9001 (80W) comes out ahead overall with 7.7/10 against 7.2/10 for the API (Allied Precision Industries) BDT250 (250W). API (Allied Precision Industries) BDT250 (250W) is stronger on freeze protection and ease of use & cleaning. K&H Pet Products Super Ice Eliminator 9001 (80W) is stronger on safety & reliability, energy efficiency, health & materials and value. At current verified prices, the K&H Pet Products Super Ice Eliminator 9001 (80W) costs about $30.64 less.
- Choose the API (Allied Precision Industries) BDT250 (250W) if: Owners of large or deep baths in very cold regions whose outlet is far from the bath, who accept a PTFE-coated base to avoid an outdoor extension cord.
- Choose the K&H Pet Products Super Ice Eliminator 9001 (80W) if: Most owners of an ordinary backyard bath who want a cheap, safety-listed, thermostatic de-icer. Small-bath owners can use the 50 W Ice Eliminator 9000 if they find it in stock.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | API (Allied Precision Industries) BDT250 (250W) | K&H Pet Products Super Ice Eliminator 9001 (80W) |
|---|---|---|
| Freeze protection | 8.4250 W with multiple thermostats, the highest output in the pool; no independent cold test found | 7.580 W, rated to −20°F; owner photo shows the bath mostly open at −18°F, though some owners report only a small patch |
| Safety & reliability | 7.5cULus, over-temperature protection, plastic-bath safe; warranty listed as 1 or 3 years depending on the seller | 8.0MET Labs certified, thermostat, 3-year warranty; must stay submerged |
| Ease of use & cleaning | 8.010-ft cord with an anti-rub protector, and the non-stick base wipes clean; tall tube form | 6.5Low-profile rock shape, but the 18-in cord needs an extension and it may float |
| Energy efficiency | 5.5Thermostatic, but 250 W is overkill for small, shallow baths and speeds evaporation | 8.580 W, and the thermostat runs it only from about 35°F to 45°F |
| Health & materials | 4.0Retailers describe the base as PTFE non-stick coated, sitting in drinking water; no PFAS-free claim | 6.8OnTheFeeder describes the K&H housing as enamel-coated aluminum; coating chemistry not disclosed |
| Value | 7.0$59.98 in stock on Amazon; it saves buying an outdoor extension cord | 9.0$28.91 from Amazon for a certified unit with a 3-year warranty |
Specifications
| Spec | API (Allied Precision Industries) BDT250 (250W) | K&H Pet Products Super Ice Eliminator 9001 (80W) |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Submersible de-icer | Submersible de-icer |
| Wattage | 250 W | 80 W |
| Thermostatically controlled | Yes | Yes |
| Claimed minimum temperature | — | -20 °F |
| Recommended bath size | Large/deep baths | Over 10 gallons |
| Cord length | 10 ft | 1.5 ft |
| Body / basin material | Aluminum base | Rock-look housing; OnTheFeeder describes K&H Ice Eliminators as enamel-coated aluminum |
| Water-contact coating | Non-stick (retailer JCS Wildlife says Teflon/PTFE) | Enamel coating (per OnTheFeeder; chemistry not disclosed) |
| Rated safe for plastic baths | Yes | Yes |
| Safety listing | cULus | MET Labs |
| Warranty | 3 years | 3 years |
API (Allied Precision Industries) BDT250 (250W)
Pros
- 250 W for large or deep baths
- Long cord, up to 10 ft
- cULus listed
- Multiple thermostats and over-temperature protection
- Safe in plastic baths
Cons
- Non-stick coating described as PTFE
- Highest energy potential of the group
- Overkill for small, shallow baths
- Cord length and warranty listed inconsistently
Worth it for large baths far from an outlet, if you accept the coating. Others should choose the API 300 or C-50.
Full API (Allied Precision Industries) BDT250 (250W) review →K&H Pet Products Super Ice Eliminator 9001 (80W)
Pros
- MET Labs certified
- Thermostat limits run time
- Safe in plastic baths
- 3-year warranty
- Budget price, sold by Amazon
Cons
- Cord is about 18 inches, so you will likely need an outdoor extension
- Light body may need weighting
- Some reviewers report only a small open patch in extreme cold
- Must stay submerged; unplug if the bath may run dry
The best choice for most owners of an ordinary backyard bath. It is inexpensive, certified and thermostat controlled, and owners report it holds up in deep cold.
Full K&H Pet Products Super Ice Eliminator 9001 (80W) review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Bird Bath Heaters of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.