Windshield Covers · Head-to-head

CAT (BDK) CAFG-200 vs FrostGuard FrostGuard Plus (Standard 59x41; XL model 53099)

CAT (BDK) CAFG-200
Best for Trucks & Large SUVs

CAT (BDK) CAFG-200

6.7/10
$25.11 at Amazon
Check price at Amazon

The short answer

FrostGuard FrostGuard Plus (Standard 59x41; XL model 53099) comes out ahead overall with 7.5/10 against 6.7/10 for the CAT (BDK) CAFG-200. CAT (BDK) CAFG-200 is stronger on fit & coverage. FrostGuard FrostGuard Plus (Standard 59x41; XL model 53099) is stronger on frost & snow protection, wind resistance & security, durability, ease of use & storage, materials & sustainability and value. At current verified prices, the CAT (BDK) CAFG-200 costs about $9.88 less.

Scores by criterion

CriterionCAT (BDK) CAFG-200FrostGuard FrostGuard Plus (Standard 59x41; XL model 53099)
Frost & Snow Protection 7.0Very wide coverage. Backing and mirror covers are unverified. 8.5Covers the wipers and both mirrors, and the PVC lining resists sticking.
Wind Resistance & Security 6.0Door flaps and straps. The strap breakage BestReviews reported is the only evidence. 7.0Has door security panels, but Popular Mechanics flags the bottom edge lifting in heavy wind.
Fit & Coverage 8.078x43 suits large vehicles. Too big for compacts. 7.0The Standard 59x41 suits cars and small SUVs. The XL is sold separately.
Durability 6.0BestReviews (the only source) notes strap breakage. 7.0Popular Science calls it industrial strength. One Walmart owner reports a panel ripping loose.
Ease of Use & Storage 7.0Machine washable but bulky. 8.5Side poles keep it taut, and the quick-dry pouch helps.
Materials & Sustainability 5.0Materials not disclosed. No magnets. 5.5Polyester with a PVC lining. No magnets, and it has a 1-year warranty.
Value 7.0$26.50 sold by Amazon, but backed by a single source. 7.5$34.99 on Amazon for the most complete feature set. Walmart lists it around $20.80 (stock unverified).

Specifications

SpecCAT (BDK) CAFG-200FrostGuard FrostGuard Plus (Standard 59x41; XL model 53099)
Attachment method Door flaps + straps Door security panels + side wraps/side poles
Width 78 in 59 in
Height 43 in 41 in
Sizes available One size 78x43 Standard 59x41; XL (Popular Science lists 68x48)
Outer material Polyester Polyester
Backing / lining material — PVC lining (stick-resistant)
Magnetic edges No No
Anti-theft door flaps Yes Yes
Side mirror covers included — Yes
Storage bag/pouch — Yes
Warranty — 1 years

CAT (BDK) CAFG-200

Pros

  • 78-inch width
  • Anti-theft door flaps
  • Machine washable
  • Sold by Amazon

Cons

  • One size only, too big for compacts
  • Straps reportedly break
  • Mirror covers and storage bag not listed
  • Backed by a single review source

Worth a look for owners of wide windshields. Others should choose a cover with more sizes.

Full CAT (BDK) CAFG-200 review →

FrostGuard FrostGuard Plus (Standard 59x41; XL model 53099)

Pros

  • Covers windshield, wipers and both mirrors
  • Door security panels
  • Stick-resistant PVC lining
  • Quick-dry pouch included
  • 1-year warranty

Cons

  • Bottom edge can lift in strong wind
  • Standard size is small
  • Priciest of the six at list
  • PVC lining and not marketed as sustainable

The best all-round pick for sedans and small SUVs. It is the easiest to set up and comes with a warranty, but it is not the best choice in heavy wind or for big windshields.

Full FrostGuard FrostGuard Plus (Standard 59x41; XL model 53099) review →

Both products are part of our guide The Best Windshield Snow & Frost Covers of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.