Electric Skillets · Head-to-head

CucinaPro XL Electric 16" Skillet (18/10 stainless) vs Presto 06857

CucinaPro XL Electric 16" Skillet (18/10 stainless)
Best Coating-Free (Stainless Steel)

CucinaPro XL Electric 16" Skillet (18/10 stainless)

7.0/10
$159.99 at Amazon
Check price at Amazon
Presto 06857
Best Large Foldaway (test data from earlier PTFE version)

Presto 06857

7.4/10
$89.99 at Amazon
Check price at Amazon

The short answer

Presto 06857 comes out ahead overall with 7.4/10 against 7.0/10 for the CucinaPro XL Electric 16" Skillet (18/10 stainless). CucinaPro XL Electric 16" Skillet (18/10 stainless) is stronger on health & materials and coating durability. Presto 06857 is stronger on cooking performance, ease of use & cleaning, capacity & versatility and value. At current verified prices, the Presto 06857 costs about $70.00 less.

Scores by criterion

CriterionCucinaPro XL Electric 16" Skillet (18/10 stainless)Presto 06857
Cooking performance 6.3Untested; bare stainless needs a full preheat and oil. 7.6Top ShouldIt evenness and pancake results, but on the PTFE unit; the ceramic version is untested, so the score is discounted.
Health & materials 8.8Uncoated 18/10 stainless; possible trace nickel/chromium with long acidic simmers. 7.6Explicit Presto PFAS-free claim; the Amazon spec block lags it, and PTFE stock may still be sold.
Coating durability 8.5No coating to wear. 6.3No long-term data on the ceramic; Presto warns dishwasher use and soaking wear the finish.
Ease of use & cleaning 6.0Removable pan, but stuck-on food takes scrubbing. 7.5Folds for storage; immersible with the control removed.
Capacity & versatility 7.816-inch round with a glass lid. 8.516-inch family surface plus foldaway storage.
Value 5.6$147–160, third-party Amazon seller, no test data. 7.3$89.99 with a 1-year warranty; coating life unknown.

Specifications

SpecCucinaPro XL Electric 16" Skillet (18/10 stainless)Presto 06857
Cooking surface / coating None – bare 18/10 stainless steel Ceramic nonstick, inside and out
Manufacturer explicitly says PFAS-free — Yes
Pan body material 18/10 stainless steel Cast aluminum
Cooking surface size 16 in round 16 in
Power 1,500 W 1,500 W
Max temperature — 400 °F
Digital controls No No
Pan lifts off heating base Yes No
Foldaway / compact storage design No Yes
Lid Tempered glass Tempered glass

CucinaPro XL Electric 16" Skillet (18/10 stainless)

Pros

  • No nonstick coating
  • Durable stainless surface
  • Large 16-inch size
  • Mid-to-premium price for the size

Cons

  • Food sticks without preheating and fat
  • No independent cooking test
  • Amazon seller is a third party
  • Harder to clean than ceramic

The right niche choice for buyers who want no nonstick chemistry. Expect a learning curve with sticking, and buy the 16-inch version.

Full CucinaPro XL Electric 16" Skillet (18/10 stainless) review →

Presto 06857

Pros

  • 16-inch cooking surface for family meals
  • Base and handles fold down for storage
  • Manufacturer states PFAS-free ceramic finish
  • Tempered glass lid and 1500 W element

Cons

  • Test data comes from the earlier PTFE version
  • Ceramic coating life is unknown
  • Presto manuals warn repeated dishwasher use wears the finish
  • Listing wording varies, so check the box

A strong format for large households short on space, as long as you verify the coating. Treat the test scores as a guide to the body and heating, not proof of the ceramic's performance.

Full Presto 06857 review →

Both products are part of our guide The Best PFAS-Free Electric Skillets of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.