Cuisinart MCPS117-16BRP1 (formerly MCP117-16BR / MCP117-16BRP1) vs Hestan 31656
Cuisinart MCPS117-16BRP1 (formerly MCP117-16BR / MCP117-16BRP1)
The short answer
Cuisinart MCPS117-16BRP1 (formerly MCP117-16BR / MCP117-16BRP1) comes out ahead overall with 8.5/10 against 8.0/10 for the Hestan 31656. Cuisinart MCPS117-16BRP1 (formerly MCP117-16BR / MCP117-16BRP1) is stronger on roasting & browning performance, stovetop searing & gravy, build quality & durability and value. Hestan 31656 is stronger on capacity, rack & handling.
- Choose the Cuisinart MCPS117-16BRP1 (formerly MCP117-16BR / MCP117-16BRP1) if: Most households that want one all-stainless clad pan for the holiday turkey, weeknight roasts and gravy made on the stovetop.
- Choose the Hestan 31656 if: All-stainless buyers who struggle to lift birds off a V-rack and don't mind a heavy pan.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Cuisinart MCPS117-16BRP1 (formerly MCP117-16BR / MCP117-16BRP1) | Hestan 31656 |
|---|---|---|
| Roasting & Browning Performance | 9.0ATK winner; even browning in ATK and Food Network tests. | 8.2Roasted well (ATK), but the trough makes potato browning uneven. |
| Stovetop Searing & Gravy | 8.5Seared without buckling (ATK); flat floor for sauces (Food Network); works on induction; no pouring lip. | 7.3Works on induction, but the trough limits searing space and deglazing. |
| Capacity, Rack & Handling | 7.8Held a 19-lb turkey and weighs 6 lb 9 oz (ATK), but the aligned rack handles make lifting awkward. | 8.2Long-side rack handles make lifting easy and it holds a 20-lb bird; heavy at 8 lb 9 oz. |
| Build Quality & Durability | 8.8Fully clad tri-ply with a lifetime warranty. | 8.318/10 tri-ply with a lifetime warranty; only one test source. |
| Ease of Cleaning | 7.0Burned-on residue takes work; avoid lemon-based detergents (Food Network). | 6.8Hand washing recommended, and the trough collects fond. |
| Health & Materials | 9.5Pan and rack are both bare stainless. | 9.5Pan and rack are both bare stainless. |
| Value | 9.0$159.95, sold by Amazon, for the test winner. | 8.0$159.95, the same as the Cuisinart, which tests better. |
Specifications
| Spec | Cuisinart MCPS117-16BRP1 (formerly MCP117-16BR / MCP117-16BRP1) | Hestan 31656 |
|---|---|---|
| Construction | Tri-ply fully clad, aluminum core | Tri-ply 18/10 stainless, aluminum core |
| Pan Length (excl. handles) | 16 in | 17 in |
| Pan Width | 12.25 in | 12.5 in |
| Pan Weight | 6.6 lb | 8.6 lb |
| Max Turkey Size | 19 lb | 20 lb |
| Rack Type | V-rack | Tension-fit rack |
| Rack Material / Coating | Uncoated stainless steel | Uncoated stainless steel |
| Oven-Safe Temperature (pan) | — | 600 °F |
| Induction Compatible | Yes | Yes |
| Warranty | Lifetime | Lifetime |
| Country of Manufacture | — | Thailand |
Cuisinart MCPS117-16BRP1 (formerly MCP117-16BR / MCP117-16BRP1)
Pros
- Won America's Test Kitchen's roasting pan test
- Fully clad tri-ply and induction compatible
- Pan and V-rack are both bare stainless steel
- Flat floor suits searing and pan sauces
- Lifetime warranty
Cons
- Rack handles line up with the pan handles, which makes unloading tricky
- No pouring lip
- Burned-on fond takes scrubbing
- The model number has changed over the years, so buy the current MCPS117-16BRP1 listing
The best all-round stainless roaster for most households. It browns well, handles stovetop work, fits a 19-pound turkey and costs less than the other clad picks. Its rack handling is the only real flaw.
Full Cuisinart MCPS117-16BRP1 (formerly MCP117-16BR / MCP117-16BRP1) review →Hestan 31656
Pros
- Rack handles on the long sides make lifting easier
- Bare stainless pan and rack
- Fully clad 18/10 tri-ply, induction compatible
- Oven-safe to 600°F
- Lifetime warranty
Cons
- Perimeter trough limits flat searing space
- Heavy at about 8 lb 9 oz
- Hand washing recommended
- A nonstick version is sold separately, so confirm model 31656
A good choice for all-stainless buyers who struggle with lifting birds, provided they accept a heavy pan and a less flat floor for gravy work.
Full Hestan 31656 review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Stainless Steel Roasting Pans with Rack of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.