Baby Bottles · Head-to-head
Dr. Brown's Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Glass, 4 oz 4-pack (SB44024) vs Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple)
Best Value Lab-Verified Anti-Colic Glass
Dr. Brown's Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Glass, 4 oz 4-pack (SB44024)
7.7/10
$31.80 at Amazon
Check price at Amazon
Best for Breastfed Babies
Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple)
7.1/10
$33.50 at Amazon
Check price at Amazon
The short answer
Dr. Brown's Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Glass, 4 oz 4-pack (SB44024) comes out ahead overall with 7.7/10 against 7.1/10 for the Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple). Dr. Brown's Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Glass, 4 oz 4-pack (SB44024) is stronger on feeding performance, health & materials, ease of use & handling and value. Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple) is stronger on ease of cleaning.
- Choose the Dr. Brown's Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Glass, 4 oz 4-pack (SB44024) if: Parents of gassy or colicky babies who want a glass bottle that has been independently lab-tested clean, at under $8 a bottle.
- Choose the Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple) if: Breastfeeding or combo-feeding parents who want a slow, sloped, breast-like nipple on a simple wide-neck glass bottle.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Dr. Brown's Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Glass, 4 oz 4-pack (SB44024) | Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple) |
|---|---|---|
| Feeding performance | 8.5Babylist and Milkology rank it top for feeding and anti-colic. Some parents see collar leaks, and the long nipple makes some babies gag. | 7.8Babylist says lactation professionals recommend it and praises the sloped nipple and vent. Its flow is slower than other brands, and there is no hands-on lab score. |
| Health & materials | 9.2Borosilicate glass, and the Options+ glass line is clean in CR's BPA, lead and phthalate test. | 7.5Borosilicate glass, and CR found no lead in the coatings in 2025, after the 2024 printed-marking lead issue. |
| Durability & breakage protection | 6.5Borosilicate glass resists thermal shock, but no sleeve is included. | 6.5Borosilicate glass resists heat, but no sleeve is included. |
| Ease of cleaning | 6.0The vent insert and reservoir add parts. It is top-rack dishwasher and sterilizer safe. | 8.0Wide neck and few parts. Babylist calls it easy to clean. |
| Ease of use & handling | 7.5The narrow neck fits standard pumps and the vent can be removed. | 7.0Wide neck and a light 5.4 oz size, but Pigeon's flow scale differs from other brands. |
| Value | 8.0$7.95 per bottle, with replacement nipples and vents widely available. | 5.5About $16.75 per bottle from a third-party seller on Amazon. |
Specifications
| Spec | Dr. Brown's Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Glass, 4 oz 4-pack (SB44024) | Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple) |
|---|---|---|
| Bottle body material | Glass | Glass |
| Glass type | Borosilicate | Borosilicate |
| Other milk-contact parts | Silicone nipple; internal vent insert/reservoir; collar | Silicone vented nipple; collar |
| BPA-free (manufacturer claim) | Yes | Yes |
| Protective sleeve/coating included | No | No |
| Available sizes | 4, 8 | 5.4, 8.1 |
| Neck type | Narrow | Wide |
| Anti-colic system | Internal vent (removable) | Vented nipple |
| Bottles in listed pack | 4 bottles | 2 bottles |
| Dishwasher safe | Yes | — |
| Approx. price per bottle | 7.95 USD | 16.75 USD |
Dr. Brown's Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Glass, 4 oz 4-pack (SB44024)
Pros
- Consumer Reports found no BPA, lead or regulated phthalates in the Options+ glass line
- Established anti-colic vent that can be removed later
- Recommended by Babylist and Milkology
- Borosilicate glass resists thermal shock
- Four-pack at a modest per-bottle cost
Cons
- More parts to clean because of the vent
- Occasional collar or nipple leaks, usually fixed by reseating
- Longer nipple can cause gagging in some babies
- Narrow neck is slower to fill
A smart pick for gassy or colicky babies, and for parents who want lab-backed materials. It ranks just behind NUK because the vent means more washing and there is no comparable hands-on lab score.
Full Dr. Brown's Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Glass, 4 oz 4-pack (SB44024) review →Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple)
Pros
- Sloped nipple designed for babies switching between breast and bottle
- Wide neck with few parts
- Easy to clean, per Babylist
- Borosilicate glass
- No detectable lead in current coatings in Consumer Reports' 2025 test
Cons
- Expensive per bottle
- 2024 lead-in-printing history on earlier bottles
- Uses its own flow-rating scale, so sizing nipples takes care
- No hands-on lab score
A good fit for combo-fed babies if the price works for you. Buy fresh stock from a trustworthy seller and take advantage of the simple, easy-to-clean design.
Full Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple) review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Glass & Non-Toxic Baby Bottles of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.