Fellow Stagg EKG Pro (1222PRO-MB-US) vs OXO 8717100
The short answer
Fellow Stagg EKG Pro (1222PRO-MB-US) comes out ahead overall with 7.6/10 against 7.0/10 for the OXO 8717100. Fellow Stagg EKG Pro (1222PRO-MB-US) is stronger on plastic-free water path, health & materials, temperature control & features and durability & support. OXO 8717100 is stronger on heating performance and value. At current verified prices, the OXO 8717100 costs about $66.32 less.
- Choose the Fellow Stagg EKG Pro (1222PRO-MB-US) if: Dedicated pour-over brewers who want temperature set to the degree, a brew timer and a controlled, steady pour, and who will pay for it.
- Choose the OXO 8717100 if: People brewing several cups who want the quickest gooseneck boil and a 1 L capacity.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Fellow Stagg EKG Pro (1222PRO-MB-US) | OXO 8717100 |
|---|---|---|
| Plastic-Free Water Path | 7.6Steel body stated by the maker; polymer on the steam-exposed inner lid is disclosed; independent coverage. | 5.5Plastic lid nubs touch condensation; silicone lid insert. |
| Health & Materials | 7.518/8 steel; plastic handle kept away from water. | 6.5Stainless interior; the maker's page was unavailable. |
| Heating Performance | 7.01200W and 0.9L; reliable in tests, though not the fastest. | 8.52.9-min boil; 2.0°F off at coffee, 6.5°F off at green tea. |
| Temperature Control & Features | 9.31° control, hold, timer and the best pour control. | 7.5Dial from 140 to 212°F, presets, 30-min hold. |
| Ease of Use & Cleaning | 7.5Excellent pour; the dial UI takes practice. | 7.5Good handle; faint markings. |
| Durability & Support | 8.5Up to 3-year warranty, and spare parts are sold. | 7.52-year warranty. |
| Value | 6.0About $180, premium. | 7.0About $118. |
Specifications
| Spec | Fellow Stagg EKG Pro (1222PRO-MB-US) | OXO 8717100 |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 0.9 L | 1 L |
| Power | 1,200 W | 1,500 W |
| Water-contact material | 304 18/8 stainless steel body | Stainless steel interior |
| Plastic touches water (per maker) | No | — |
| Silicone/polymer exposed to water or steam | Polymer on inner lid, steam-exposed (Mamavation); handle/lid pull BPA-free plastic or wood | TechGearLab: condensation contacts small plastic nubs on the lid underside. CoffeeGeek notes a silicone lid insert. |
| Variable temperature | Yes | Yes |
| Temperature presets | — | 5 presets |
| Keep-warm / hold | 60 min | 30 min |
| Double-wall body | No | — |
| Gooseneck spout | Yes | Yes |
| Warranty | 2 years | 2 years |
| Temperature range | 104-212 | 140-212 |
| Plastic contact found in independent test (TechGearLab) | None detected on original Stagg EKG (TechGearLab); Pro inferred via ASIN link only | Yes - plastic nubs on lid |
Fellow Stagg EKG Pro (1222PRO-MB-US)
Pros
- 304 18/8 stainless steel body
- 1° control from 104 to 212°F
- Hold of up to 60 minutes and a brew timer
- Recommended by Food Network, Reviewed and Tom's Guide
- Replacement parts sold; warranty extends to three years with registration
Cons
- Small 0.9L capacity
- Premium price
- No audible alert at set temperature
- Steam-exposed polymer piece on the inner lid, per Mamavation
- Plastic power base
The Stagg EKG Pro is the best overall choice for coffee and tea drinkers who care about plastic. It is not perfectly plastic-free, but its steel body, strong independent track record and repair support make it the most dependable kettle here. Expect to pay a premium.
Full Fellow Stagg EKG Pro (1222PRO-MB-US) review →OXO 8717100
Pros
- Fastest boil of the goosenecks tested
- 1 L capacity
- Strong accuracy at coffee temperature
- 2-year warranty
- Recommended by America's Test Kitchen
Cons
- Plastic nubs on the lid touch condensation
- About 6.5°F hot at green-tea settings
- Faint level markings and no water window
- Buttons feel cheap
A strong all-rounder for batch brewers who value speed, provided the lid plastic does not bother you.
Full OXO 8717100 review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Gooseneck Electric Kettles for Pour-Over of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.