Cinco (Good Tidings) C-148 Classic vs Krinner Tree Genie XXL (94720)
The short answer
Krinner Tree Genie XXL (94720) comes out ahead overall with 8.5/10 against 7.6/10 for the Cinco (Good Tidings) C-148 Classic. Cinco (Good Tidings) C-148 Classic is stronger on value. Krinner Tree Genie XXL (94720) is stronger on stability & grip, ease of setup & takedown, water capacity & refilling, build quality & durability and safety & materials. At current verified prices, the Cinco (Good Tidings) C-148 Classic costs about $95.55 less.
- Choose the Cinco (Good Tidings) C-148 Classic if: Budget buyers with live trees up to 10 ft who don't mind turning bolts.
- Choose the Krinner Tree Genie XXL (94720) if: Anyone setting up a live tree of 7–12 ft, especially one person working alone or someone with a crooked trunk.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Cinco (Good Tidings) C-148 Classic | Krinner Tree Genie XXL (94720) |
|---|---|---|
| Stability & grip | 8.0Its low, wide base took more than 15 lb of force to tip per HGTV (snippet only), so the score is held at 8.0. | 8.5The five-claw single cable gives equal pressure on the trunk (Bob Vila), and Popular Mechanics found the Deluxe version handles crooked trunks. No direct XXL impact or pull figure is published, so the score is capped at 8.5. |
| Ease of setup & takedown | 6.3Standard bolt centering. Solo mounting is harder than with a Krinner. | 9.3One person locks the tree with a foot pedal, with no crawling or bolt-turning. WRAL (2013) found the release snaps open abruptly. |
| Water capacity & refilling | 7.81.75–2 gal with a spill guard and no indicator. | 9.22.5 gal with a level indicator, the largest reservoir here. It spills if overfilled (Bob Vila), and the float stuck in WRAL's dated 2013 test. |
| Build quality & durability | 6.8Plastic body. The 10-year warranty comes only from HGTV and is unverified, and there are missing-hardware reports. | 8.0German-made with a 5-year warranty and spare indicators sold, but the body and claws are plastic. |
| Safety & materials | 7.5Good capacity for hydration and a rust-proof body. | 8.5The large reservoir keeps a live tree hydrated, which lowers fire risk (NFPA), and replacement parts are available. |
| Value | 8.8About $43, the cheapest stand here rated to 10 ft. Value is scored down slightly because the warranty is unverified. | 7.0$129 at Krinner, $138 on Amazon, roughly 4x a plastic bolt stand. The price is justified for big trees and solo setup. |
Specifications
| Spec | Cinco (Good Tidings) C-148 Classic | Krinner Tree Genie XXL (94720) |
|---|---|---|
| Tree type | Live | Live |
| Stand type | Plastic bolt stand | Cable-and-claw foot-pedal |
| Securing mechanism | Adjustment bolts with centering pins | Foot-pedal ratchet tightens single cable with 5 claws |
| Max tree height | 10 ft | 12 ft |
| Max trunk / pole diameter | 6 in | 7 in |
| Water capacity | 1.75 gal | 2.5 gal |
| Water-level indicator | No | Yes |
| Primary material | Plastic | Plastic body and claws with steel cable/gears |
| Stand weight | — | 18 lb |
| Rotating | No | No |
| Built-in outlets | No | No |
| Warranty | 10 years per HGTV (not confirmed by manufacturer) | 5 years (per Krinner XXL manual) |
Cinco (Good Tidings) C-148 Classic
Pros
- Budget price
- Rated for 10-ft trees and 6-in trunks
- Low, wide base
- Spill guard
- Rust-proof plastic
Cons
- Reports of missing hardware
- Bolts can be hard to align
- Mounting alone is harder than with a Krinner
- No water-level indicator
A sound budget stand for a mid-size tree. Plan on two people and a little patience at setup.
Full Cinco (Good Tidings) C-148 Classic review →Krinner Tree Genie XXL (94720)
Pros
- One person can set up and plumb the tree
- Grips crooked trunks evenly
- 2.5-gal reservoir, the largest here
- Holds trunks up to 7 in
- 5-year warranty and replacement water indicators sold separately
Cons
- Priced well above bolt stands
- Plastic claws and pedal can break if misused
- The reservoir can spill if overfilled
- A 2013 test reported a sticking float and an abrupt release, which may predate the current design
The easiest big-tree stand to use, and the one we would buy for most live trees. You pay a premium for the setup and the large reservoir. Krinner's own store lists it below the third-party Amazon price.
Full Krinner Tree Genie XXL (94720) review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Christmas Tree Stands of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.