GreenLife CC003725-002 (Turquoise; Black CC004777-001) vs Presto 06854

GreenLife CC003725-002 (Turquoise; Black CC004777-001)
The short answer
GreenLife CC003725-002 (Turquoise; Black CC004777-001) comes out ahead overall with 7.5/10 against 6.9/10 for the Presto 06854. GreenLife CC003725-002 (Turquoise; Black CC004777-001) is stronger on cooking performance, ease of use & cleaning and value. Presto 06854 is stronger on capacity & versatility. At current verified prices, the GreenLife CC003725-002 (Turquoise; Black CC004777-001) costs about $122.00 less.
- Choose the GreenLife CC003725-002 (Turquoise; Black CC004777-001) if: Two- to four-person households who want an affordable, dishwasher-safe skillet whose PFAS-free ceramic version was itself independently tested.
- Choose the Presto 06854 if: Cooks who want a digital readout, a rack and deep sides in a 16-inch skillet with a consistent manufacturer PFAS-free claim.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | GreenLife CC003725-002 (Turquoise; Black CC004777-001) | Presto 06854 |
|---|---|---|
| Cooking performance | 7.6ShouldIt test of the PFAS-free ceramic unit: pancake 8.2, steak 7.7, 11.85% heat variance. | 6.8No independent test; scored conservatively. |
| Health & materials | 8.0Explicit PFAS-free claim on GreenLife's page and in ShouldIt's description; the wording is narrower on GreenPan-hosted pages. | 7.8Explicit PFAS-free claim from Presto. |
| Coating durability | 6.0Sol-gel release fades over time; owners report brittle plastic legs and handles. | 6.3Marketed as 'ultra-durable' but not verified. |
| Ease of use & cleaning | 8.0Dishwasher-safe pan, vented glass lid, compact. | 7.3Digital readout; large pan that isn't removable. |
| Capacity & versatility | 6.312-inch square, 5 qt; for 2–4 people. | 8.016 inches with high sides and a rack. |
| Value | 8.8$49.99 for the only PFAS-free unit with an independent test. | 5.8$159.99 and untested. |
Specifications
| Spec | GreenLife CC003725-002 (Turquoise; Black CC004777-001) | Presto 06854 |
|---|---|---|
| Cooking surface / coating | Ceramic nonstick (sol-gel) | Ceramic nonstick, inside and out |
| Manufacturer explicitly says PFAS-free | Yes | Yes |
| Pan body material | Aluminum | Cast aluminum |
| Cooking surface size | 12 in square | 16 in (extra-high sides) |
| Capacity | 5 qt | — |
| Power | 1,200 W | 1,500 W |
| Digital controls | No | Yes |
| Pan lifts off heating base | No | No |
| Pan dishwasher-safe (per manufacturer/listing) | Yes | — |
| Foldaway / compact storage design | No | No |
| Lid | Glass, vented | Glass cover |
GreenLife CC003725-002 (Turquoise; Black CC004777-001)
Pros
- Independent test covered the PFAS-free ceramic version
- Dishwasher-safe pan and vented glass lid
- Low price for a tested pick
- Even enough heat for pancakes and eggs
Cons
- Owners report the plastic legs and handles break
- Heat is less even than the best large pans (11.85% variance in testing)
- 1200 W limits searing
- Too small for large households
The best fit for this guide. It combines a clear PFAS-free claim with independent test results on the same coating, at a budget price. Handle it gently and it suits small to mid-size households well.
Full GreenLife CC003725-002 (Turquoise; Black CC004777-001) review →Presto 06854
Pros
- 16-inch surface with extra-high sides
- Digital controller
- Rack for steaming, baking and sous vide
- Consistent manufacturer PFAS-free wording
Cons
- No independent test
- Premium price
- Does not fold away
- Coating life unknown
A versatile large option for buyers who value features. Treat it as an informed bet, not a proven performer.
Full Presto 06854 review →Both products are part of our guide The Best PFAS-Free Electric Skillets of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.
