Le Creuset Essential Non-stick Ceramic Shallow Fry Pan 12" (51314030001001) vs OXO Ceramic Professional 12" Frypan (CC004742-001)

Le Creuset Essential Non-stick Ceramic Shallow Fry Pan 12" (51314030001001)

OXO Ceramic Professional 12" Frypan (CC004742-001)
The short answer
Le Creuset Essential Non-stick Ceramic Shallow Fry Pan 12" (51314030001001) and OXO Ceramic Professional 12" Frypan (CC004742-001) finish almost level in our scoring (7.6 vs 7.7 out of 10), so the right pick depends on what you value most. Le Creuset Essential Non-stick Ceramic Shallow Fry Pan 12" (51314030001001) is stronger on durability & coating longevity, health & materials and set composition. OXO Ceramic Professional 12" Frypan (CC004742-001) is stronger on cooking performance and value. At current verified prices, the OXO Ceramic Professional 12" Frypan (CC004742-001) costs about $33.97 less.
- Choose the Le Creuset Essential Non-stick Ceramic Shallow Fry Pan 12" (51314030001001) if: Buyers who will pay more for a tested, metal-utensil-safe ceramic pan with 10 years of coverage and a choice of four sizes.
- Choose the OXO Ceramic Professional 12" Frypan (CC004742-001) if: Cooks who want an ATK-proven durable 12" ceramic pan that works on induction, for less than the premium brands.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Le Creuset Essential Non-stick Ceramic Shallow Fry Pan 12" (51314030001001) | OXO Ceramic Professional 12" Frypan (CC004742-001) |
|---|---|---|
| Cooking performance | 8.0ATK says it browned well and released food easily. | 8.3Widest surface in ATK's test and Taste of Home's best for searing; needs oil at lower heat. |
| Durability & coating longevity | 8.2Stayed nonstick through ATK testing; the 10-year warranty comes from the manufacturer. | 7.8Passed both of ATK's 50-egg tests; owner reports of coating failure and warranty denials take a little off. |
| Health & materials | 7.5Le Creuset says plainly that the coating is 'made without PFAS'; made in China. | 7.0Amazon and Target listings say free of PFAS, lead and cadmium; OXO's own wording varies. |
| Ease of use & cleaning | 7.0Induction-ready and oven-safe to 550°F, but short walls and an awkward handle; hand-washing recommended. | 7.3Dishwasher-safe and induction-ready, but heavy with high straight walls. |
| Set composition | 8.0Four sizes from 8" to 12". | 6.0Only the 12" in the pool; no lid. |
| Value | 6.8$124 is high, partly offset by the warranty. | 8.6$89.99 at Amazon; the cheapest pan that passed ATK's durability tests. Warranty terms are unverified, so they don't count here. |
Specifications
| Spec | Le Creuset Essential Non-stick Ceramic Shallow Fry Pan 12" (51314030001001) | OXO Ceramic Professional 12" Frypan (CC004742-001) |
|---|---|---|
| Cooking surface / coating | All-over ceramic nonstick | Diamond-reinforced ceramic nonstick |
| Manufacturer explicitly states PFAS-free | Yes | Yes |
| Body construction | Forged heavy-gauge aluminum with stainless steel base | Hard-anodized aluminum with induction base |
| Pieces (as marketed) | 1 pieces | 1 pieces |
| Fry pan / skillet sizes | 12" (also 8", 10", 11") | 12" |
| Oven-safe temperature (pans) | 550 °F | 600 °F |
| Induction compatible | Yes | Yes |
| Dishwasher safe (per maker) | Yes | Yes |
| Metal-utensil safe | Yes | — |
| Warranty | 10 years | Lifetime limited (per Target listing) |
| Made in | China | — |
| Pan weight | — | 3.06 lb |
Le Creuset Essential Non-stick Ceramic Shallow Fry Pan 12" (51314030001001)
Pros
- Stayed nonstick in ATK testing
- Plain 'made without PFAS' claim
- 10-year warranty
- Metal-utensil safe
- Four sizes available
Cons
- Expensive
- Short walls
- Awkward handle angle
- Hand-wash recommended
A good premium choice for buyers who value the warranty and utensil tolerance. It costs more than the OXO or GreenPan without clearly outperforming them.
Full Le Creuset Essential Non-stick Ceramic Shallow Fry Pan 12" (51314030001001) review →OXO Ceramic Professional 12" Frypan (CC004742-001)
Pros
- Passed both ATK 50-egg tests
- Broadest cooking surface in ATK's test
- Strong searing
- Induction-compatible and oven-safe to 600°F
- Dishwasher-safe
Cons
- Heavy, at about 3 lb
- Slow to heat
- Needs oil at lower heat
- Warranty terms unclear
The best value for a tested, induction-ready ceramic pan. It gives up a little handling ease to GreenPan but costs less and has a similar durability record.
Full OXO Ceramic Professional 12" Frypan (CC004742-001) review →Both products are part of our guide The Best PFAS-Free Ceramic Nonstick Frying Pans of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.