NUK Simply Natural Glass, 4 oz 3-pack vs Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple)
Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple)
The short answer
NUK Simply Natural Glass, 4 oz 3-pack comes out ahead overall with 7.9/10 against 7.1/10 for the Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple). NUK Simply Natural Glass, 4 oz 3-pack is stronger on feeding performance, health & materials and value. Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple) is stronger on ease of cleaning. At current verified prices, the NUK Simply Natural Glass, 4 oz 3-pack costs about $13.51 less.
- Choose the NUK Simply Natural Glass, 4 oz 3-pack if: Most parents who want a glass bottle that scored well in hands-on tests, resists leaks and has a wide neck, at the lowest per-bottle price.
- Choose the Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple) if: Breastfeeding or combo-feeding parents who want a slow, sloped, breast-like nipple on a simple wide-neck glass bottle.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | NUK Simply Natural Glass, 4 oz 3-pack | Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple) |
|---|---|---|
| Feeding performance | 8.3BabyGearLab gave it 79/100 overall, the best of the glass bottles it tested, and 9/10 for leakage. The nipple must be positioned correctly. | 7.8Babylist says lactation professionals recommend it and praises the sloped nipple and vent. Its flow is slower than other brands, and there is no hands-on lab score. |
| Health & materials | 8.0Borosilicate glass and 8/10 eco-health from BabyGearLab. The CPSC recall applied to a different UK-market product. No CR chemical test. | 7.5Borosilicate glass, and CR found no lead in the coatings in 2025, after the 2024 printed-marking lead issue. |
| Durability & breakage protection | 6.5No sleeve, and BestReviews advises checking for hairline cracks. | 6.5Borosilicate glass resists heat, but no sleeve is included. |
| Ease of cleaning | 7.5Wide neck, few parts, top-rack dishwasher safe. | 8.0Wide neck and few parts. Babylist calls it easy to clean. |
| Ease of use & handling | 7.0The wide neck is easy to fill, but the white markings are hard to read (Mommyhood101). | 7.0Wide neck and a light 5.4 oz size, but Pigeon's flow scale differs from other brands. |
| Value | 9.0$6.66 per bottle with the top tested glass score. | 5.5About $16.75 per bottle from a third-party seller on Amazon. |
Specifications
| Spec | NUK Simply Natural Glass, 4 oz 3-pack | Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple) |
|---|---|---|
| Bottle body material | Glass | Glass |
| Glass type | Borosilicate | Borosilicate |
| Other milk-contact parts | Medical-grade silicone nipple; collar | Silicone vented nipple; collar |
| BPA-free (manufacturer claim) | Yes | Yes |
| Protective sleeve/coating included | No | No |
| Available sizes | 4, 8 | 5.4, 8.1 |
| Neck type | Wide | Wide |
| Anti-colic system | Vent in nipple | Vented nipple |
| Bottles in listed pack | 3 bottles | 2 bottles |
| Dishwasher safe | Yes | — |
| Empty weight (BabyGearLab measured) | 5.8 oz | — |
| Approx. price per bottle | — | 16.75 USD |
NUK Simply Natural Glass, 4 oz 3-pack
Pros
- BabyGearLab Editors' Choice for glass (79/100)
- Leakage scored 9/10 in hands-on testing
- Wide neck and few parts make cleaning easy
- Borosilicate body, BPA-free
- Lowest cost per bottle in this lineup
Cons
- White volume markings are hard to read
- Asymmetrical nipple needs careful positioning
- No protective sleeve included
- Reviewers note it may encourage a lazy latch in some breastfed babies
The most balanced glass bottle we found. Strong hands-on results, a wide neck and a low per-bottle cost make it the default choice for most parents. Add a sleeve separately if drops worry you.
Full NUK Simply Natural Glass, 4 oz 3-pack review →Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple)
Pros
- Sloped nipple designed for babies switching between breast and bottle
- Wide neck with few parts
- Easy to clean, per Babylist
- Borosilicate glass
- No detectable lead in current coatings in Consumer Reports' 2025 test
Cons
- Expensive per bottle
- 2024 lead-in-printing history on earlier bottles
- Uses its own flow-rating scale, so sizing nipples takes care
- No hands-on lab score
A good fit for combo-fed babies if the price works for you. Buy fresh stock from a trustworthy seller and take advantage of the simple, easy-to-clean design.
Full Pigeon Glass Nursing Bottle Wide Neck 5.4 oz/160 mL 2-pack (SS nipple) review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Glass & Non-Toxic Baby Bottles of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.