OLLY Kids Multi + Probiotic - 70 Count vs Renzo's Picky Eater Multi: Which Should You Buy? (2026)

The short answer

Renzo's Picky Eater Multi comes out ahead overall with 8.8/10 against 8.5/10 for the OLLY Kids Multi + Probiotic - 70 Count. OLLY Kids Multi + Probiotic - 70 Count is stronger on quality testing & transparency, ease of use and value. Renzo's Picky Eater Multi is stronger on formula quality & age appropriateness and ingredient profile. At current verified prices, the OLLY Kids Multi + Probiotic - 70 Count costs about $12.00 less.

Scores by criterion

Criterion	OLLY Kids Multi + Probiotic - 70 Count	Renzo's Picky Eater Multi
Formula Quality & Age Appropriateness	8.0Provides core vitamins, choline, iodine and zinc plus Bacillus coagulans probiotic. Formula is useful but less broad than several higher-scoring competitors.	9.2Broad 18-vitamin-and-mineral formula including iron, iodine, zinc, selenium and chromium, with methylfolate and methylcobalamin forms.
Quality Testing & Transparency	9.3NSF Certified with independent testing and certification covering quality, safety and label claims.	9.0Third-party laboratory tested and Clean Label Project Certified. Manufactured in an NSF-certified facility, although facility certification is not treated as NSF product certification.
Ingredient Profile	7.2Contains sugar and glucose syrup with 1-2 g added sugar per daily serving depending on age, and uses gelatin.	9.0Zero sugar, vegan, gluten-free and non-GMO, with no artificial flavors or sweeteners. Uses sugar alcohols including mannitol and xylitol, which may matter for individual tolerance.
Ease of Use	9.0Straightforward gummy format requiring one gummy daily for ages 2-3 or two gummies daily for ages 4+.	8.5Melty tablets can be dissolved, chewed, swallowed or mixed into liquid. Children ages 4+ require two tablets daily, while ages 2-3 require half a tablet.
Value	9.3Normalized value score using cost per daily serving for a 5-year-old child across the initial 10-product evaluation pool. Current cost: $0.40 per day. Category range: $0.25 to $1.30 per day.	7.1Normalized value score using cost per daily serving for a 5-year-old child across the initial 10-product evaluation pool. Current cost: $0.87 per day. Category range: $0.25 to $1.30 per day.

Specifications

Spec	OLLY Kids Multi + Probiotic - 70 Count	Renzo's Picky Eater Multi
Recommended Age	Ages 2+	Ages 2+
Minimum Age	2 years	2 years
Form	Gummy	Melty Tablet
Daily Dose	1 gummy daily for ages 2-3; 2 gummies daily for ages 4+	1/2 tablet daily for ages 2-3; 2 tablets daily for ages 4+
Servings Per Container	70 servings ages 2-3; 35 servings ages 4+	120 daily servings ages 2-3; 30 daily servings ages 4+
Daily Nutrients Count	13	18
Contains Iron	No	Yes
Contains Omega-3	No	No
Contains Choline	Yes	No
Contains Zinc	Yes	Yes
Contains Iodine	Yes	Yes
Contains Added Sugar	Yes	No
Added Sugar Per Daily Serving	1 g ages 2-3; 2 g ages 4+	0 g
Third-Party Tested	Yes	Yes
NSF Certified	Yes	—
Clean Label Project Certified	—	Yes
Sweetener Type	Sugar and glucose syrup	Mannitol, xylitol and monk fruit
Artificial Flavors	—	No
Vegan	No	Yes
Gluten-Free	Yes	Yes
Non-GMO	—	Yes

OLLY Kids Multi + Probiotic - 70 Count

Pros

Includes a probiotic alongside core vitamins and minerals
NSF Certified
One of the lowest-cost options in our comparison

Cons

Less comprehensive nutrient coverage than several competitors
Contains added sugar, glucose syrup and gelatin

Full OLLY Kids Multi + Probiotic - 70 Count review →

Renzo's Picky Eater Multi

Pros

Broad 18-nutrient formula including iron, iodine and zinc
Zero added sugar with Clean Label Project certification
Melty tablets can be chewed, dissolved, swallowed or mixed into liquid

Cons

Contains iron, which may not be appropriate or necessary for every child
Contains sugar alcohols including xylitol and mannitol

Full Renzo's Picky Eater Multi review →

Both products are part of our guide Best Kids Multivitamins of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.