Owala 24oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler, no handle) vs Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636

Owala 24oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler, no handle)

Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636
The short answer
Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636 comes out ahead overall with 7.3/10 against 7.1/10 for the Owala 24oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler, no handle). Owala 24oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler, no handle) is stronger on ease of use & cleaning. Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636 is stronger on temperature retention and value. At current verified prices, the Owala 24oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler, no handle) costs about $10.00 less.
- Choose the Owala 24oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler, no handle) if: Desk or car users who want the lowest upfront price for a lead-free straw tumbler sold by Amazon and don't need 40 oz.
- Choose the Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636 if: Anyone who wants a big Stanley-style handled straw cup from a brand that says it has never used lead.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Owala 24oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler, no handle) | Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636 |
|---|---|---|
| Lead-Free Verification | 7.5Brand-level statement and one bottle XRF result. This model is untested. | 7.5Owala's lead-free solder statement has been the same since launch. The one XRF non-detect was on a bottle, and the tumbler is untested. |
| Temperature Retention | 7.0No published test for this size. | 8.0Based on ATK's Recommended rating and Owala's 24-hour cold claim. No hour-by-hour data. |
| Lid & Leak Resistance | 5.5Spill-resistant lid, not leakproof. | 5.5Splash-resistant only, and ATK found all straw tumblers leaked when tipped. |
| Ease of Use & Cleaning | 7.5Light and handle-free, with a top-rack-safe lid. | 7.0Handle, fits cup holders, top-rack-safe lid. Hand-washing the cup is recommended. |
| Durability | 7.0No notable failures reported. | 7.0No major failures reported, though some users find it top-heavy. |
| Health & Materials | 8.0BPA- and phthalate-free lid and straw. | 8.0Stainless interior, and Owala says its plastics are BPA- and phthalate-free. |
| Value | 7.0Lowest upfront cost, but about $1.25/oz. | 8.0About $1.00/oz, sold by Amazon and in stock. |
Specifications
| Spec | Owala 24oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler, no handle) | Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636 |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 24 oz | 40 oz |
| Manufacturer Lead-Free Seal Statement | Yes – Owala FAQ: lead-free solder since founding | Yes – Owala FAQ: 'Owala Bottles Are Lead Free. Always Have Been'; lead-free solder used 'from the very beginning' |
| Independent Lead Test of Seal | Lead Safe Mama XRF (2022) on one Owala bottle: sealing dot non-detect (not this model) | Lead Safe Mama XRF (2022): sealing dot non-detect for lead on one Owala bottle (not this tumbler) |
| Interior Material | Stainless steel | Stainless steel |
| Lid Type | Spill-resistant lid with straw | 2-in-1 splash-resistant lid (removable straw or open swig) |
| Straw Included | Yes | Yes |
| Handle | No | Yes |
| Fully Leakproof When Closed | No | No |
| Claimed Cold Retention | — | 24 hours |
| Dishwasher Safe | Lid top-rack; cup hand-wash recommended | Lid top-rack; cup technically yes but Owala recommends hand-washing |
| Fits Most Cup Holders | — | Yes |
Owala 24oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler, no handle)
Pros
- Lowest upfront price among the straw tumblers
- Same Owala lead-free statement as the 40 oz
- Compact, suited to desks and car use
- BPA- and phthalate-free lid and straw
- Sold by Amazon and in stock
Cons
- Spill-resistant lid, not leakproof
- Costs more per ounce than the 40 oz
- No independent test of this size
- Owala recommends hand-washing the cup
A sensible compact choice when upfront cost matters most. If you'll use the capacity, the 40 oz is the better value per ounce.
Full Owala 24oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler, no handle) review →Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636
Pros
- Most editorial support in the lineup (ATK, BestReviews)
- Lead-free statement from Owala covers solder from the start
- Handle and straw included
- Cupholder-friendly
- Sold by Amazon and in stock
Cons
- Lid is splash-resistant, not leakproof
- Owala recommends hand-washing the cup
- Some reviewers find the handle awkward or the cup top-heavy
A strong choice if you want a large straw tumbler and trust Owala's lead-free statement. It ranks below the SmoothSip because the lid isn't leakproof.
Full Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636 review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Lead-Free Insulated Tumblers of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.