Insulated Tumblers · Head-to-head

Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636 vs Zojirushi SM-KHE48

Zojirushi SM-KHE48
Best for Hot Coffee

Zojirushi SM-KHE48

7.0/10
$23.49 at Amazon
Check price at Amazon

The short answer

Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636 comes out ahead overall with 7.3/10 against 7.0/10 for the Zojirushi SM-KHE48. Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636 is stronger on lead-free verification, ease of use & cleaning, health & materials and value. Zojirushi SM-KHE48 is stronger on temperature retention, lid & leak resistance and durability. At current verified prices, the Zojirushi SM-KHE48 costs about $16.50 less.

Scores by criterion

CriterionOwala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636Zojirushi SM-KHE48
Lead-Free Verification 7.5Owala's lead-free solder statement has been the same since launch. The one XRF non-detect was on a bottle, and the tumbler is untested. 4.5The only statement is Zojirushi's customer-service answers on Target. No published policy or independent XRF test.
Temperature Retention 8.0Based on ATK's Recommended rating and Owala's 24-hour cold claim. No hour-by-hour data. 9.0Reviewed.com: best 24-hour heat retention of the mugs it tested. Zojirushi: 147°F after 6 hours.
Lid & Leak Resistance 5.5Splash-resistant only, and ATK found all straw tumblers leaked when tipped. 8.5Locking flip-top that seals shut. A few users report leaks.
Ease of Use & Cleaning 7.0Handle, fits cup holders, top-rack-safe lid. Hand-washing the cup is recommended. 6.0Hand-wash only, though the lid comes apart for cleaning. Slim and light.
Durability 7.0No major failures reported, though some users find it top-heavy. 7.5Long-running model. A reseller cites a 5-year warranty on the insulation that I did not verify on Zojirushi's site.
Health & Materials 8.0Stainless interior, and Owala says its plastics are BPA- and phthalate-free. 7.5Unlined 18/8 steel and BPA-free lid. The DBP is only in the base sticker adhesive.
Value 8.0About $1.00/oz, sold by Amazon and in stock. 6.5$39.99 for 16 oz (about $2.50/oz), the highest per-ounce price in the lineup.

Specifications

SpecOwala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636Zojirushi SM-KHE48
Capacity 40 oz 16 oz
Manufacturer Lead-Free Seal Statement Yes – Owala FAQ: 'Owala Bottles Are Lead Free. Always Have Been'; lead-free solder used 'from the very beginning' Yes – Zojirushi brand-expert answers on Target: mug is lead free; 'does not use lead in the manufacturing of the stainless steel vacuum insulated mugs, bottles and tumblers'
Independent Lead Test of Seal Lead Safe Mama XRF (2022): sealing dot non-detect for lead on one Owala bottle (not this tumbler) None found
Interior Material Stainless steel 18/8 stainless steel with SlickSteel electro-polished finish (no nonstick coating)
Lid Type 2-in-1 splash-resistant lid (removable straw or open swig) Locking flip-top lid
Straw Included Yes No
Handle Yes No
Fully Leakproof When Closed No Yes
Claimed Cold Retention 24 hours 6 hours
Claimed Hot Retention — 6 hours
Dishwasher Safe Lid top-rack; cup technically yes but Owala recommends hand-washing No – hand wash
Fits Most Cup Holders Yes —

Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636

Pros

  • Most editorial support in the lineup (ATK, BestReviews)
  • Lead-free statement from Owala covers solder from the start
  • Handle and straw included
  • Cupholder-friendly
  • Sold by Amazon and in stock

Cons

  • Lid is splash-resistant, not leakproof
  • Owala recommends hand-washing the cup
  • Some reviewers find the handle awkward or the cup top-heavy

A strong choice if you want a large straw tumbler and trust Owala's lead-free statement. It ranks below the SmoothSip because the lid isn't leakproof.

Full Owala 40oz Tumbler (Triple Layer Insulated Travel Tumbler with Handle), C05636 review →

Zojirushi SM-KHE48

Pros

  • Top heat retention in Reviewed's testing
  • Locking lid seals shut
  • Unlined 18/8 stainless interior
  • BPA-free plastic parts
  • Sold by Amazon and in stock

Cons

  • Lead-free statement comes from customer service, not a published policy or test
  • Hand-wash only
  • Holds only 16 oz
  • Bottom sticker adhesive contains DBP, which Zojirushi says doesn't touch the drink

The best choice for hot coffee, but the weakest lead-free case in the guide. Buy it for performance if you're comfortable with Zojirushi's statement.

Full Zojirushi SM-KHE48 review →

Both products are part of our guide The Best Lead-Free Insulated Tumblers of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.