PickMetric
Hamilton Beach Professional Cast Iron Electric Grill/Griddle 38560
Electric Griddles

Hamilton Beach 38560

#3 · Best Cast Iron (No Coating)
7.4 /10 Our score
Lowest verified price $164.95 Amazon
Our verdict
A strong option for buyers who prefer iron to ceramic and are willing to maintain it. Note that warranty terms are reported inconsistently, so check the listing before you buy.

Pros

  • No nonstick coating
  • Excellent searing and heat retention
  • Even heat for pancakes
  • Reaches 450°F
  • Removable plate

Cons

  • Heavy and needs seasoning and hand-washing
  • Eggs stick until seasoned
  • Can run very hot
  • Modest 160 sq in cooking area

Disclosure: We may earn a commission when you purchase through links on this page. This does not affect our editorial rankings.

View best price at Amazon
Last reviewed November 7, 2026
Review

What to know about Hamilton Beach 38560

A 10 x 16 inch pre-seasoned cast-iron electric griddle that reaches 450°F, with no nonstick coating. Food Network named it 'Best Cast-Iron' for even heat and excellent searing. It's heavy and needs seasoning care.
Editorial notes

Why it stands out

Why we like it

Bare iron needs no PFAS statement. Food Network gave it Best Cast-Iron, citing excellent heat retention and even heat distribution. Burgers seared quickly and evenly with excellent crust, and pancakes cooked with little color variation.

The plate is removable and a drip tray catches grease. Seasoning improves with use, so the surface can get better over time rather than wear out.

What to know

Skip it if you want a low-maintenance, lightweight griddle. Food Network said eggs initially stuck to the unseasoned surface, and the griddle can run very hot, leaving less margin for error.
Performance

Score breakdown

Cooking performance

Even heat across the surface, accurate temperature control, ability to sear and to cook pancakes/eggs without hot or cold spots, based on independent tests (ATK, TechGearLab, Food Network, Reviewed).

8.5
Food Network: even heat and excellent burger crust, but it runs very hot.
Health & materials

Explicit manufacturer PFAS-free claim (not just PFOA-free) or an uncoated surface (cast iron or stainless); conflicting disclosures lower the score.

9.0
Uncoated cast iron with no coating at all, though no formal manufacturer claim.
Coating durability & food release

How well the nonstick or seasoned surface releases food and holds up over time; staining, sticking after months, and dishwasher degradation count against it.

7.0
Food Network says the surface is extremely durable, but eggs stuck until the seasoning built up.
Ease of cleaning

Removable or immersible plates, dishwasher-safe parts, drip trays, and how easily baked-on residue comes off.

5.0
Heavy hand-wash cast iron that needs careful cleaning and maintenance (Food Network).
Capacity & versatility

Usable cooking area, grease management/tilt, extra functions (grill plates, warming tray, lid) and storability.

6.0
Small 160 sq in surface with a drip tray.
Value

Performance and materials relative to typical street price.

7.0
About $137 for a coating-free plate with a multi-year warranty.
Specifications

Hamilton Beach 38560 specs

Materials

Cooking surface material
Pre-seasoned cast iron (no nonstick coating)

Capacity

Cooking surface area
160 sq in
Cooking surface dimensions
10 x 16 in

Performance

Maximum temperature
450 °F
Wattage
1800 W

Cleaning

Removable cooking plate
Yes

Design

Grease management
Drip tray
Lid or cover included
No
Shopping

Compare prices

Prices are checked periodically. Older amounts are labeled with their last verification date.

Disclosure: We may earn a commission when you purchase through links on this page. This does not affect our editorial rankings.

Prices and availability may change. The retailer's price and availability at checkout govern the transaction.

RetailerPriceAvailability
AmazonLowest $164.95 In Stock View deal
Target Check price at retailer Check at retailer Check at retailer
Best Buy Check price at retailer Check at retailer Check at retailer
Lowest verified price $164.95
30-day low $136.64
90-day average $146.08
90-day low $136.64

Based on 3 retailer price observations captured during the last 90 days.

More coverage

Guides featuring Hamilton Beach 38560

The Best Non-Toxic PFAS-Free Electric Griddles of 2026 Best Cast Iron (No Coating) · #3
Head-to-head

Compare the Hamilton Beach 38560 with

Hamilton Beach 38560 vs Presto 07023 Hamilton Beach 38560 vs Presto 07062 Hamilton Beach 38560 vs Presto 07046 Hamilton Beach 38560 vs BALMUDA The Teppanyaki