Toasters

KitchenAid KMT2115SX

#4 · Best Compact Verified-Materials 2-Slice
6.7 /10 Our score
Lowest verified price $79.95 Amazon
Our verdict
A fit for singles and couples who put materials evidence ahead of browning results. If you want proven toast, choose the GE or Magimix instead.

Pros

  • Mamavation 'Best' tier placement
  • Sold by Amazon.com
  • Manual high lift
  • Bagel mode
  • Compact footprint

Cons

  • No accessible independent browning test
  • Mixed owner reports on evenness
  • Owners describe loud beeps and visible fingerprints
  • Prop 65 warning on the listing

Disclosure: We may earn a commission when you purchase through links on this page. This does not affect our editorial rankings.

View best price at Amazon
Last reviewed November 11, 2026
Review

What to know about KitchenAid KMT2115SX

The compact 2-slot sibling of the KMT4115, with extra-wide slots, a manual high-lift lever, a 5-level shade control and a bagel function that cuts one side's element to 50%. Mamavation lists the KMT2115 in its 'Best' non-toxic tier.
Editorial notes

Why it stands out

Why we like it

It shares the KMT4115's Mamavation 'Best' tier placement, meaning no PFAS or nano-ceramic coatings and no zinc or aluminum food-contact surfaces. It is the in-stock 2-slot toaster in that tier sold by Amazon itself.

The bagel mode cuts one side's element to 50 percent, and the manual high lift makes it easy to retrieve small items.

What to know

Skip it if tested browning matters most. Consumer Reports has tested it but the results are paywalled, we found no other lab test, and owner reports on evenness are mixed. A Prop 65 warning appears on the listing.
Performance

Score breakdown

Toasting Performance

Evenness and consistency of browning across the slice, side to side and batch to batch; bagel and frozen performance, per independent tests (ATK, TechGearLab, Reviewed, RTINGS).

6.0
No accessible lab test; owner reviews conflict on evenness.
Health & Materials

No disclosed non-stick/PFAS coating on food-contact parts, stainless/glass/mica construction, minimal black plastic, Prop 65 status and manufacturer transparency (AB 1200 disclosures, Mamavation/My Chemical Free House findings).

8.0
Mamavation 'Best' tier (placement only); Prop 65 warning reported on one color variant.
Build, Durability & Repairability

Construction quality, longevity, owner-reported failures, warranty length and availability of replacement parts/elements.

6.5
Stainless build, 1-year warranty, no parts sold.
Ease of Use & Features

Controls, high-lift lever, bagel/defrost/reheat functions, crumb tray access, exterior heat and cleaning.

7.5
High lift and bagel mode; loud beeps.
Capacity & Versatility

Slice capacity, slot width/length for artisan bread and bagels, independent controls.

6.0
2 extra-wide slots.
Value

Performance and material quality relative to typical street price.

6.5
$79.95 is a premium paid mainly for the materials verification.
Specifications

KitchenAid KMT2115SX specs

Capacity

Slice capacity
2 slices
Long slot
No

Performance

Shade settings
5 settings
Heating element type
Wire

Materials

Housing material
Brushed stainless steel
Non-stick coating disclosed on food-contact parts
No
Prop 65 warning reported
Yes

Durability

Replaceable elements/parts sold
No
Warranty
1 years
Shopping

Compare prices

Prices are checked periodically. Older amounts are labeled with their last verification date.

Disclosure: We may earn a commission when you purchase through links on this page. This does not affect our editorial rankings.

Prices and availability may change. The retailer's price and availability at checkout govern the transaction.

RetailerPriceAvailability
AmazonLowest $79.95 $79.99 In Stock View deal
Walmart Check price at retailer Check at retailer Check at retailer
Lowest verified price $79.95
30-day low $79.95
90-day average $79.95
90-day low $79.95

Based on 2 retailer price observations captured during the last 90 days.

More coverage

Guides featuring KitchenAid KMT2115SX

Head-to-head

Compare the KitchenAid KMT2115SX with