Amazon Basics 10-Cup Pitcher (Brita-compatible filter) vs PUR PPT111W (PUR PLUS 11-Cup, PPF951K filter)
Amazon Basics 10-Cup Pitcher (Brita-compatible filter)
PUR PPT111W (PUR PLUS 11-Cup, PPF951K filter)
The short answer
PUR PPT111W (PUR PLUS 11-Cup, PPF951K filter) comes out ahead overall with 7.4/10 against 6.5/10 for the Amazon Basics 10-Cup Pitcher (Brita-compatible filter). Amazon Basics 10-Cup Pitcher (Brita-compatible filter) is stronger on value, flow & daily convenience and reliability & support. PUR PPT111W (PUR PLUS 11-Cup, PPF951K filter) is stronger on pfas reduction evidence, other contaminant coverage and health, materials & sustainability. At current verified prices, the Amazon Basics 10-Cup Pitcher (Brita-compatible filter) costs about $25.23 less.
- Choose the Amazon Basics 10-Cup Pitcher (Brita-compatible filter) if: Budget buyers who accept independently lab-tested, rather than certified, PFAS reduction for filters that cost about $0.09 per gallon.
- Choose the PUR PPT111W (PUR PLUS 11-Cup, PPF951K filter) if: Most households that want a Total-PFAS-certified pitcher that fits in the fridge and keeps the water's minerals, at about $108 a year in filters (buy PPF951K replacements).
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Amazon Basics 10-Cup Pitcher (Brita-compatible filter) | PUR PPT111W (PUR PLUS 11-Cup, PPF951K filter) |
|---|---|---|
| PFAS reduction evidence | 5.0No PFAS certification; one independent result (TechGearLab, 87%). | 8.8IAPMO Total PFAS listing W-29904 (via TapWaterData) plus 97% in TechGearLab's test. The 99.75% figure is PUR's own claim. |
| Other contaminant coverage | 6.0Certified for 9 contaminants including lead; no fluoride or arsenic reduction. | 8.0TechGearLab measured 100% lead, arsenic, uranium and microplastics, but only 14% fluoride. |
| Value | 9.3$24.77, with filters at about $0.09 per gallon (Water Filter Guru). | 6.8$50 on Amazon from a third-party seller. Filters cost about $108 a year, roughly $0.22 per gallon. |
| Installation & cabinet fit | 7.5Standard 10-cup fridge pitcher. | 7.511-cup pitcher that fits a standard fridge shelf. |
| Flow & daily convenience | 6.540-gallon filter; also takes Brita filters. | 5.5About 30–34 minutes per gallon, with a small fill opening. Has an LED filter-change light; filters last 40 gallons. |
| Health, materials & sustainability | 5.0Sodium rose from 162 to 267 ppm and silver appeared after filtration (Water Filter Guru). | 6.5Plastic body; the product page doesn't state BPA-free. Leaves minerals in and doesn't change pH. |
| Reliability & support | 6.5Sold by Amazon; many compatible filters. | 5.5TechGearLab reported the lid breaking off. Replacement filters are easy to find. |
Specifications
| Spec | Amazon Basics 10-Cup Pitcher (Brita-compatible filter) | PUR PPT111W (PUR PLUS 11-Cup, PPF951K filter) |
|---|---|---|
| Filter type | Activated carbon + ion-exchange resin cartridge | Activated carbon + ion exchange gravity cartridge (PUR PLUS PPF951K) |
| PFAS certification (as stated by maker) | None (certified NSF/ANSI 42/53/401/372 for other contaminants) | IAPMO R&T, NSF/ANSI 53 Total PFAS, certificate W-29904 (TapWaterData, verified 2026-08-30); 99.75% is PUR's datasheet claim |
| Third-party certified for PFAS | No | Yes |
| Independent lab total PFAS reduction | 87 % | 97 % |
| Filter capacity (primary cartridge) | 40 gal | 40 gal |
| Rated filter life | 2 months | 2 months |
| Est. annual filter cost | 43 USD | 108 USD |
| Pure-to-drain ratio (RO) | N/A (no wastewater) | N/A (no wastewater) |
| Needs electrical outlet | No | No |
| Uses dedicated faucet (drilling may be needed) | No | No |
| Water capacity | 10 cups | 11 cups |
| Pitcher body material | Plastic | Plastic |
Amazon Basics 10-Cup Pitcher (Brita-compatible filter)
Pros
- 87% PFAS reduction in TechGearLab testing
- Lowest running cost
- Low purchase price
- Fits Brita-compatible filters
Cons
- No PFAS certification
- Water Filter Guru found sodium rising and silver appearing in filtered water
- No fluoride or arsenic reduction
Best value, with a clear caveat: its PFAS performance rests on lab tests, not certification. Fine for tight budgets, second to PUR for assurance.
Full Amazon Basics 10-Cup Pitcher (Brita-compatible filter) review →PUR PPT111W (PUR PLUS 11-Cup, PPF951K filter)
Pros
- Certified for Total PFAS under NSF/ANSI 53
- 97% total PFAS removal in lab testing
- Removes lead, arsenic, uranium and microplastics
- Moderate annual filter cost
- Leaves minerals and pH alone
Cons
- Slow, about 30 to 34 minutes per gallon
- TechGearLab had the flip-top lid break
- Small fill opening
- The Amazon listing is from a third-party seller
The strongest mix of certification, lab results and running cost in this group. It is slow and the lid is a weak point, but it is the pitcher most households should buy.
Full PUR PPT111W (PUR PLUS 11-Cup, PPF951K filter) review →Both products are part of our guide The Best PFAS-Removing Water Filter Pitchers of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.