Best Choice Products 7.5ft Pre-Lit Spruce, 550 lights (SKY2888) vs National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO)
Best Choice Products 7.5ft Pre-Lit Spruce, 550 lights (SKY2888)
National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO)
The short answer
Best Choice Products 7.5ft Pre-Lit Spruce, 550 lights (SKY2888) comes out ahead overall with 6.5/10 against 6.3/10 for the National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO). Best Choice Products 7.5ft Pre-Lit Spruce, 550 lights (SKY2888) is stronger on realism & fullness, lighting quality and value. National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) is stronger on branch strength & ornament support, setup, fluffing & storage and durability & warranty. At current verified prices, the National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) costs about $45.17 less.
- Choose the Best Choice Products 7.5ft Pre-Lit Spruce, 550 lights (SKY2888) if: Buyers who want a tested full-size 7.5 ft pre-lit tree with light modes for no more than $200.
- Choose the National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) if: Apartment dwellers who need a floor-standing pre-lit tree under 5 ft.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Best Choice Products 7.5ft Pre-Lit Spruce, 550 lights (SKY2888) | National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) |
|---|---|---|
| Realism & Fullness | 6.5Reviewed tested it hands-on and found it slim but convincing once fluffed; 1,346 PVC tips is medium density. | 6.0Full for its size (Bob Vila), but only 4.5 ft. |
| Branch Strength & Ornament Support | 6.0No sagging complaints from Reviewed; metal stand. | 6.5The top branch held a topper; the tips suit small to medium ornaments. |
| Setup, Fluffing & Storage | 7.0Hinged sections and lights already strung; fluffing takes real time. | 8.0About 20 minutes to set up (Bob Vila). |
| Lighting Quality | 6.5550 lights with three modes; LED only per Amazon's title. | 5.5Subtle lights, and light count and color vary by variant. |
| Durability & Warranty | 5.0No warranty found; some owners report light-string failures. | 5.5Warranty not confirmed for this SKU. |
| Health & Materials | 6.0PVC; mild odor on arrival faded within 48 hours (Reviewed). | 6.0PVC tips. |
| Value | 7.5Tested and pre-lit at $199.99, but no headroom under the cap. | 6.5About $107 for 4.5 ft is fair but not cheap per foot. |
Specifications
| Spec | Best Choice Products 7.5ft Pre-Lit Spruce, 550 lights (SKY2888) | National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) |
|---|---|---|
| Height | 7.5 ft | 4.5 ft |
| Branch tips | 1,346 tips | — |
| Profile | slim/medium | full |
| Pre-lit | Yes | Yes |
| Number of lights | 550 lights | — |
| Light type | twinkling lights; retailers conflict on LED vs incandescent | pre-lit (variant listings conflict on clear, warm LED or multicolor) |
| Needle/tip material | PVC | PVC |
| Flocked | No | No |
| Hinged branches | Yes | Yes |
Best Choice Products 7.5ft Pre-Lit Spruce, 550 lights (SKY2888)
Pros
- Recommended by a hands-on tester
- 550 pre-strung lights with twinkle, slow-glow and steady modes
- Hinged 1,346-tip frame sets up easily
- Full-size 7.5 ft height under $200
- In stock on Amazon at the cap
Cons
- Looks thin until fluffed
- Slight odor on arrival that faded within 48 hours
- No warranty found
- Priced right at the $200 limit, so there is no headroom
- LED versus incandescent differs between listings
The best all-around choice under $200 for a full-size pre-lit tree. It is not flawless, but it is the best-supported option in the budget and it saves you the work of lighting a tree yourself.
Full Best Choice Products 7.5ft Pre-Lit Spruce, 550 lights (SKY2888) review →National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO)
Pros
- Tested by Bob Vila, who named it Best Small
- About 20 minutes to assemble and fluff
- Full shape for its size
- Sturdy top branch holds a topper
- Sold by Amazon.com
Cons
- Only 4.5 ft tall
- Branches suit small to medium ornaments
- Light color and count vary by variant, so check the listing
- No warranty found
The right choice for apartments and tight corners. It is not the pick for a living room tree.
Full National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Artificial Christmas Tree Under $200 of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.