Best Choice Products 7.5ft Premium Unlit Spruce (SKY2887) vs National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO)
Best Choice Products 7.5ft Premium Unlit Spruce (SKY2887)
National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO)
The short answer
Best Choice Products 7.5ft Premium Unlit Spruce (SKY2887) and National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) finish almost level in our scoring (6.4 vs 6.3 out of 10), so the right pick depends on what you value most. Best Choice Products 7.5ft Premium Unlit Spruce (SKY2887) is stronger on lighting quality, durability & warranty, health & materials and value. National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) is stronger on branch strength & ornament support and setup, fluffing & storage. At current verified prices, the Best Choice Products 7.5ft Premium Unlit Spruce (SKY2887) costs about $39.83 less.
- Choose the Best Choice Products 7.5ft Premium Unlit Spruce (SKY2887) if: Buyers who want the cheapest full-size 7.5 ft tree from an established brand and will add their own lights.
- Choose the National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) if: Apartment dwellers who need a floor-standing pre-lit tree under 5 ft.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Best Choice Products 7.5ft Premium Unlit Spruce (SKY2887) | National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) |
|---|---|---|
| Realism & Fullness | 6.0PVC needles look papery up close; medium fullness. Same frame as Reviewed's tested pre-lit version. | 6.0Full for its size (Bob Vila), but only 4.5 ft. |
| Branch Strength & Ornament Support | 5.5Budget PVC branches; no heavy-ornament test found. | 6.5The top branch held a topper; the tips suit small to medium ornaments. |
| Setup, Fluffing & Storage | 6.5Hinged with a foldable base; needs thorough fluffing. | 8.0About 20 minutes to set up (Bob Vila). |
| Lighting Quality | 6.0Unlit; hinged branches make wrapping your own strings straightforward. | 5.5Subtle lights, and light count and color vary by variant. |
| Durability & Warranty | 6.0No built-in lights to fail; no warranty stated. | 5.5Warranty not confirmed for this SKU. |
| Health & Materials | 6.5PVC; you can choose your own LEDs. | 6.0PVC tips. |
| Value | 8.5About $110 for a full-size tree from a known brand. | 6.5About $107 for 4.5 ft is fair but not cheap per foot. |
Specifications
| Spec | Best Choice Products 7.5ft Premium Unlit Spruce (SKY2887) | National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) |
|---|---|---|
| Height | 7.5 ft | 4.5 ft |
| Branch tips | 1,346 tips | — |
| Profile | full | full |
| Pre-lit | No | Yes |
| Number of lights | 0 lights | — |
| Light type | none (unlit) | pre-lit (variant listings conflict on clear, warm LED or multicolor) |
| Needle/tip material | PVC | PVC |
| Flocked | No | No |
| Hinged branches | Yes | Yes |
Best Choice Products 7.5ft Premium Unlit Spruce (SKY2887)
Pros
- Lowest price for a 7.5 ft hinged tree in this guide
- Same 1,346-tip frame as our top pick
- Recommended by NBC Select
- Foldable metal base
- Lights can be chosen and replaced separately
Cons
- Needles look papery up close
- Only medium-full for 7.5 ft and needs thorough fluffing
- Not pre-assembled and large for some homes
- No warranty found
The best value for buyers who will add their own lights. It saves real money and gives you a full-height tree, as long as you are willing to fluff and light it.
Full Best Choice Products 7.5ft Premium Unlit Spruce (SKY2887) review →National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO)
Pros
- Tested by Bob Vila, who named it Best Small
- About 20 minutes to assemble and fluff
- Full shape for its size
- Sturdy top branch holds a topper
- Sold by Amazon.com
Cons
- Only 4.5 ft tall
- Branches suit small to medium ornaments
- Light color and count vary by variant, so check the listing
- No warranty found
The right choice for apartments and tight corners. It is not the pick for a living room tree.
Full National Tree Company 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Dunhill Fir (DUH-45RLO) review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Artificial Christmas Tree Under $200 of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.