Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) vs Hestan 48650
Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13)
The short answer
Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) and Hestan 48650 finish almost level in our scoring (7.4 vs 7.3 out of 10), so the right pick depends on what you value most. Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) is stronger on food release & cleanup and value. Hestan 48650 is stronger on baking & roasting performance and warp resistance & durability. At current verified prices, the Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) costs about $64.95 less.
- Choose the Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) if: Buyers who want to see published PFAS lab results before buying nonstick.
- Choose the Hestan 48650 if: Buyers who want no coating and no exposed aluminum, and will pay for a pan that never warps.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) | Hestan 48650 |
|---|---|---|
| Baking & Roasting Performance | 7.2Overbrowned cookie edges in Prudent Reviews' test. | 7.8The aluminum core gives even heat; stainless browns less readily. |
| Warp Resistance & Durability | 7.0Buckles at high heat but flattens again once cool; ceramic wears over time. | 9.5No warping in two independent tests; rated to 600°F. |
| Health & Materials (PFAS-Free) | 8.8Explicit PFAS-free claim backed by published third-party tests. | 8.8Inert stainless with no coating; docked for nickel. |
| Food Release & Cleanup | 8.5Strong ceramic release; hand wash only. | 4.5Severe sticking and rainbow stains. |
| Size, Fit & Handling | 7.0Half-sheet size, but heavy with hot handles. | 7.0Handles help, but it weighs 4.5 lb. |
| Value | 5.8More than twice the price of the USA Pan nonstick. | 5.0About 5x the price of aluminum. |
Specifications
| Spec | Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) | Hestan 48650 |
|---|---|---|
| Body Material | Aluminized steel core, stainless steel handles | Tri-ply: stainless steel / aluminum core / stainless steel |
| Food-Contact Surface | Ceramic (sol-gel) nonstick coating | Stainless steel |
| Coating | Ceramic, made without PTFE/PFOA/PFAS | None |
| Manufacturer Explicitly States PFAS-Free | Yes | — |
| Exterior Dimensions | 18 x 13 | 21 x 13.75 x 1.1 (with handles) |
| Cooking Surface | — | 18 x 13 |
| Pans Included | 1 pcs | 1 pcs |
| Weight | 3.7 lb | 4.5 lb |
| Max Oven Temperature | 550 °F | 600 °F |
| Dishwasher Safe (per maker) | No | Yes |
| Made in USA | No | No |
| Warranty | — | Lifetime |
Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13)
Pros
- Published third-party PFAS test results
- Easy release and cleanup
- Rated to 550°F
- Stainless handles
Cons
- Overbrowned cookie edges in Prudent Reviews' test
- Handles run hot
- Buckles at high heat but flattens once cool
- Expensive and heavy; ceramic release fades over time
Worth it if documentation matters most to you. Others bake better for less.
Full Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) review →Hestan 48650
Pros
- Did not warp in testing
- Stainless food surface
- Rated to 600°F
- Lifetime warranty
Cons
- Food sticks badly
- Hardest to clean in Prudent Reviews' test
- Heavy at 4.5 pounds
- Very expensive
A durable, coating-free luxury pan. Most cooks will get more value from the Nordic Ware.
Full Hestan 48650 review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Non-Toxic (PFAS-Free) Baking Sheets of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.