Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) vs Nordic Ware 44600 (Amazon: 44600AMZ)
Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13)
Nordic Ware 44600 (Amazon: 44600AMZ)
The short answer
Nordic Ware 44600 (Amazon: 44600AMZ) comes out ahead overall with 8.2/10 against 7.4/10 for the Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13). Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) is stronger on health & materials (pfas-free), food release & cleanup and size, fit & handling. Nordic Ware 44600 (Amazon: 44600AMZ) is stronger on baking & roasting performance, warp resistance & durability and value. At current verified prices, the Nordic Ware 44600 (Amazon: 44600AMZ) costs about $36.38 less.
- Choose the Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) if: Buyers who want to see published PFAS lab results before buying nonstick.
- Choose the Nordic Ware 44600 (Amazon: 44600AMZ) if: Budget shoppers and batch roasters whose ovens fit a 21 x 15 in pan.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) | Nordic Ware 44600 (Amazon: 44600AMZ) |
|---|---|---|
| Baking & Roasting Performance | 7.2Overbrowned cookie edges in Prudent Reviews' test. | 8.8Same aluminum as the ATK winner; ATK Highly Recommended. |
| Warp Resistance & Durability | 7.0Buckles at high heat but flattens again once cool; ceramic wears over time. | 8.5Steel-reinforced rim; ATK rated it as sturdy as the winner. |
| Health & Materials (PFAS-Free) | 8.8Explicit PFAS-free claim backed by published third-party tests. | 8.5Uncoated, and the maker says PFAS-free; aluminum reacts with acids. |
| Food Release & Cleanup | 8.5Strong ceramic release; hand wash only. | 5.5Needs a liner; hand wash only. |
| Size, Fit & Handling | 7.0Half-sheet size, but heavy with hot handles. | 6.5Oversized; won't fit smaller ovens or standard racks. |
| Value | 5.8More than twice the price of the USA Pan nonstick. | 9.2Lowest price in the lineup for the most cooking area. |
Specifications
| Spec | Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) | Nordic Ware 44600 (Amazon: 44600AMZ) |
|---|---|---|
| Body Material | Aluminized steel core, stainless steel handles | Pure aluminum, encapsulated steel rim |
| Food-Contact Surface | Ceramic (sol-gel) nonstick coating | Bare aluminum |
| Coating | Ceramic, made without PTFE/PFOA/PFAS | None (uncoated) |
| Manufacturer Explicitly States PFAS-Free | Yes | Yes |
| Exterior Dimensions | 18 x 13 | 21 x 15 x 1 |
| Cooking Surface | — | 19.5 x 13.5 (ATK) / 20.3 x 14.3 (Amazon listing) |
| Pans Included | 1 pcs | 1 pcs |
| Weight | 3.7 lb | 2 lb |
| Max Oven Temperature | 550 °F | 500 °F |
| Dishwasher Safe (per maker) | No | No |
| Made in USA | No | Yes |
| Warranty | — | Lifetime limited |
Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13)
Pros
- Published third-party PFAS test results
- Easy release and cleanup
- Rated to 550°F
- Stainless handles
Cons
- Overbrowned cookie edges in Prudent Reviews' test
- Handles run hot
- Buckles at high heat but flattens once cool
- Expensive and heavy; ceramic release fades over time
Worth it if documentation matters most to you. Others bake better for less.
Full Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18x13) review →Nordic Ware 44600 (Amazon: 44600AMZ)
Pros
- Lowest price in the lineup
- Large cooking area
- No coating
- Sturdy in ATK's testing
- Safe to 500°F
Cons
- Won't fit many ovens
- Food sticks without parchment
- Bare aluminum reacts with acidic foods
- Hand wash only
A great value if your oven is big enough. Otherwise buy the half sheet.
Full Nordic Ware 44600 (Amazon: 44600AMZ) review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Non-Toxic (PFAS-Free) Baking Sheets of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.