Hatch Restore 3 (HBR4901G Greige / HBR4902P Putty / HBR4903C Cocoa) vs Lumie Bodyclock Shine 300
Hatch Restore 3 (HBR4901G Greige / HBR4902P Putty / HBR4903C Cocoa)
The short answer
Lumie Bodyclock Shine 300 comes out ahead overall with 7.7/10 against 7.4/10 for the Hatch Restore 3 (HBR4901G Greige / HBR4902P Putty / HBR4903C Cocoa). Hatch Restore 3 (HBR4901G Greige / HBR4902P Putty / HBR4903C Cocoa) is stronger on alarm & sound, ease of use, features & versatility and health & materials. Lumie Bodyclock Shine 300 is stronger on sunrise light quality and reliability & build.
- Choose the Hatch Restore 3 (HBR4901G Greige / HBR4902P Putty / HBR4903C Cocoa) if: People who want one bedside device for wind-down sounds, a sunrise wake-up and a routine, and don't mind using an app.
- Choose the Lumie Bodyclock Shine 300 if: Anyone who wants the brightest, most adjustable sunrise without an app, Wi-Fi or a subscription.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Hatch Restore 3 (HBR4901G Greige / HBR4902P Putty / HBR4903C Cocoa) | Lumie Bodyclock Shine 300 |
|---|---|---|
| Sunrise light quality | 7.5610 lux at 1 ft, ~285 at 18 in, 5-60 min ramp (OYB) | 9.0Brightest traditional clock in OYB's test (730 lux at 1 ft, ~360 at 18 in); 15-90 min sunrise and sunset |
| Alarm & sound | 8.560+ high-quality sounds, the best library in the pool; can't play your own audio | 7.015 sounds plus FM radio; smaller library than Hatch's |
| Ease of use | 7.0Physical controls added, but Wi-Fi and app setup are needed | 6.5App-free, but the menu takes days to learn (OYB) and it shows 24-hour time only (NBC) |
| Features & versatility | 8.5Sound machine, routines, reading and night light, wind-down content | 7.5Sunset, reading light, night light, FM; no Bluetooth or smart features |
| Reliability & build | 6.51-year warranty; depends on Wi-Fi and Hatch's cloud | 8.03-year warranty when bought direct; no cloud dependency; Amazon seller is a third party |
| Health & materials | 7.5Clean flicker (OYB); the 2024 CPSC adapter recall covered the Rest 1st gen, not the Restore | 7.0Class I medical device (UK/EU); OYB measured ~200 Hz flicker when dimmed |
| Value | 6.5$149.99 on Amazon, but the full library needs a $49.99/yr subscription | 6.8$169 at Lumie or Amazon, no subscription; buy direct to keep the trial and warranty |
Specifications
| Spec | Hatch Restore 3 (HBR4901G Greige / HBR4902P Putty / HBR4903C Cocoa) | Lumie Bodyclock Shine 300 |
|---|---|---|
| Measured brightness at 18 in | 285 lux | 360 lux |
| Longest sunrise duration | 60 min | 90 min |
| Sunrise duration options | 5-60 min (Optimize Your Biology) | 15-90 min |
| Sunset / wind-down light | — | Yes |
| Built-in sounds | 60 sounds | 15 sounds |
| FM radio | No | Yes |
| Bluetooth audio | No | No |
| App required for setup/core use | Yes | No |
| Subscription | Optional Hatch+ $4.99/mo or $49.99/yr (30-day trial included) | None |
| Power source | Plug-in | Plug-in |
| Warranty | 1 years | 3 years |
Hatch Restore 3 (HBR4901G Greige / HBR4902P Putty / HBR4903C Cocoa)
Pros
- 60+ sounds and a routine builder
- Physical controls that work without a phone
- Clean flicker in independent testing
- 5 to 60 minute sunrise
- Frequently named best overall by testers
Cons
- Needs Wi-Fi and the app
- Full library requires Hatch+ at $49.99 a year
- Dimmer than the Shine 300
- 1-year warranty
- Cannot play your own audio
The best choice if the bedside device matters as much as the alarm. It ranks below the Lumie because of the app dependence, subscription content and lower brightness.
Full Hatch Restore 3 (HBR4901G Greige / HBR4902P Putty / HBR4903C Cocoa) review →Lumie Bodyclock Shine 300
Pros
- Brightest traditional clock in independent light-meter testing
- Sunrise and sunset from 15 to 90 minutes
- 15 sounds plus FM radio
- No app, Wi-Fi or subscription
- 3-year warranty and 45-day trial when bought from Lumie
Cons
- Menu takes days to learn
- 24-hour time only
- Flicker is in the risky band when dimmed
- Premium price
The best sunrise alarm for anyone who values light output and control over extras. Buy it directly from Lumie, which sells it at the same price as Amazon and describes the 3-year warranty and 45-day trial for direct purchases. The Amazon listing is from a third-party seller.
Full Lumie Bodyclock Shine 300 review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Sunrise Alarm Clocks of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.