Caraway 10-Cup Coffee Maker (Clean Brew System) vs SimplyGoodCoffee THE BREWER - Plastic-Free (1st Gen), 8-Cup
SimplyGoodCoffee THE BREWER - Plastic-Free (1st Gen), 8-Cup
The short answer
SimplyGoodCoffee THE BREWER - Plastic-Free (1st Gen), 8-Cup comes out ahead overall with 7.7/10 against 6.8/10 for the Caraway 10-Cup Coffee Maker (Clean Brew System). SimplyGoodCoffee THE BREWER - Plastic-Free (1st Gen), 8-Cup is stronger on coffee quality, health & materials transparency, ease of use & cleaning, durability & repairability and value.
- Choose the Caraway 10-Cup Coffee Maker (Clean Brew System) if: Buyers who need a 10-cup plastic-free automatic, are comfortable with an unverified new product, and can pre-order direct and wait about three months (Batch 4 is estimated to ship January 26).
- Choose the SimplyGoodCoffee THE BREWER - Plastic-Free (1st Gen), 8-Cup if: Anyone who wants a one-button 8-cup drip brewer where only glass, stainless steel and silicone touch water and coffee, bought on Amazon today.
Scores by criterion
| Criterion | Caraway 10-Cup Coffee Maker (Clean Brew System) | SimplyGoodCoffee THE BREWER - Plastic-Free (1st Gen), 8-Cup |
|---|---|---|
| Plastic-Free Brew Path | 9.0Manufacturer-claimed glass and stainless path with a stainless filter. Not independently verified. | 9.0Glass tank and carafe, stainless path and basket. Only the silicone seals and tubing are neither glass nor metal. |
| Coffee Quality | 6.5Claims 195-205°F. No independent lab or taste data yet. | 8.0Controlled 195-205°F and SCA Gold Cup claim. Tom's Guide tested it favorably. |
| Health & Materials Transparency | 7.0AB1200 compliance and a third-party test page. The PFAS claim appears only in a review Caraway requested. | 7.5Itemized materials and a no-aluminum claim. No PFAS statement or UL/ETL listing shown. |
| Ease of Use & Cleaning | 6.5One dial. No delay timer, and the basket and filter need washing after every brew. | 7.0One button and no kettle needed, but no timer, a non-removable tank and an easily bumped drip-stop (Bob Vila). |
| Durability & Repairability | 5.52-year warranty and no track record. | 6.55-year replacement warranty needs proof of purchase or registration. Third-party Amazon seller, and the model is superseded. |
| Value | 4.5About $496 with a roughly 3-month ship wait. | 6.5$430.99 on Amazon is the cheapest fully plastic-free automatic machine available there. |
Specifications
| Spec | Caraway 10-Cup Coffee Maker (Clean Brew System) | SimplyGoodCoffee THE BREWER - Plastic-Free (1st Gen), 8-Cup |
|---|---|---|
| Brewer Type | Automatic drip | Automatic drip |
| Brew Capacity | — | 40 oz |
| Water Reservoir Material | Glass | Borosilicate glass |
| Brew Basket / Filter Holder Material | Stainless steel basket with reusable stainless filter | 304 stainless steel |
| Carafe Material | Glass (stainless lid with silicone edge) | Borosilicate glass |
| Plastic-Free Hot Brew Path (as shipped) | Yes | Yes |
| Explicit PFAS-Free Claim by Manufacturer | — | No |
| Programmable Timer | No | No |
| Brew Temperature | 195-205°F | 195-205°F |
| Power | — | 1,540 W |
| SCA / ECBC Certified | — | Yes |
| Warranty | 2 years | 5 years |
Caraway 10-Cup Coffee Maker (Clean Brew System)
Pros
- 10-cup capacity
- Glass reservoir and carafe, stainless path and filter
- Reusable stainless filter means no paper
- Strong placement in plastic-free roundups
Cons
- About three months to ship
- 2-year warranty
- No delay timer; basket and filter need washing after every brew
- Not on Amazon, and no SCA certification
On paper it fits this guide's focus as well as any machine. Because it is new, direct-only and unproven in independent tests, it ranks below the options you can buy and evaluate today.
Full Caraway 10-Cup Coffee Maker (Clean Brew System) review →SimplyGoodCoffee THE BREWER - Plastic-Free (1st Gen), 8-Cup
Pros
- Glass reservoir, carafe and stainless hot path
- One-button operation, no kettle needed
- Brews at 195-205°F and is listed to Gold Cup / SCA standard
- 5-year warranty
- Recommended by many independent plastic-free guides
Cons
- No delay timer
- Reservoir is not removable, and bumping the drip-stop can cause overflow (Bob Vila)
- Exterior is plastic and tubing is silicone
- Brand makes no PFAS statement
This is the 1st Gen model, sold on Amazon by a third-party seller. The brand now sells a 2nd Gen Programmable version direct, with a 24-hour timer, but it is currently out of stock on Amazon. If a timer matters, buy that one from the brand. Otherwise this is the best fit for anyone who wants an automatic brewer with a genuinely glass-and-steel brew path.
Full SimplyGoodCoffee THE BREWER - Plastic-Free (1st Gen), 8-Cup review →Both products are part of our guide The Best Plastic-Free / Non-Toxic Drip Coffee Makers of 2026, where you can see every pick, how we score and current prices from each retailer.